ThePumpkins.net

...Said Sadly [4]
Ugly [7]
God [4]-
Mouths of Babes [15]
Rotten Apples [22]
Transformer [16]+

...Said Sadly [3]-
Ugly [7]
God [5]
Mouths of Babes [15]
Rotten Apples [23]+
Transformer [15]

OK...all songs that have already participated in preveious games have been pulled from the list. Trying to keep the list as short as possible, I left out Pastachio Medley because it's not really a song, but a conglomoration of song ideas. I Left out Tonight Reprise because it's just an extension of Tonight Tonight.

And as we disucssed in the other thread, we're starting everything at 3 points. We'll just see how it goes, but if the point totals get high and there's still a ton of songs left, we'll either nuke everything some points or re-set them all or whatever...we'll just figure that out when the time comes.

We have 23 songs here starting with 3 points each.

...Said Sadly [3]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [3]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [3]
The Boy [3]
Cherry [3]
Believe [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [3]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [3]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medilla of the Grey Skies [3]
Blank [3]
The Last Song [3]
Transformer [3]
The Bells [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

and my vote for today:

...Said Sadly [3]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [3]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [3]
The Boy [3]
Cherry [3]
Believe [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]+
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [3]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medilla of the Grey Skies [3]
Blank [3]
The Last Song [3]
Transformer [3]
The Bells [2]-
My Blue Heaven [3]

...Said Sadly [3]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [3]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [3]
The Boy [3]
Cherry [3]
Believe [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [3]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [3]
Blank [3]
The Last Song [4]+
Transformer [3]
The Bells [1]-
My Blue Heaven [3]

"The Last Song" is one of my favorite Pumpkins songs, definitely in the top 20 at least. I might even go so far to say I like it better than "Set the Ray To Jerry" in terms of TAFH songs.

I am of the same mind, "The Bells"= one of the worst James Iha songs

..Said Sadly [4]+
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [3]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [3]
The Boy [3]
Cherry [3]
Believe [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [3]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [3]
Blank [3]
The Last Song [4]
Transformer [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

The Bells is gone

...Said Sadly [3]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [2]-
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [3]
The Boy [4]+
Cherry [3]
Believe [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [3]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [3]
Blank [3]
The Last Song [4]
Transformer [3]
The Bells [1]
My Blue Heaven [3]

JeePee and I went at the same time so here is the list:

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [2]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [3]
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
Believe [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [3]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [3]
Blank [3]
The Last Song [4]
Transformer [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [1]-
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [4]+
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
Believe [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [3]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [3]
Blank [3]
The Last Song [4]
Transformer [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

Am I missing something?

"Believe" is on Judas O isn't it?

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [1]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [4]
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [4]+
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [3]
Blank [2]-
The Last Song [4]
Transformer [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

Dammit, I couldn't save "The Bells"...

How can it be one of the worst Iha songs?

It's better than "...Said Sadly" by far.

EDIT: Okay, I think it's just an honest mistake that "Believe" is in there, so I removed it from the list. Aren't I a good person?

Ah, so many of these songs are my favourite haha.
+ I liked the bells, not James' best (cough cough "GO") but Its a good song none the less.

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [1]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [4]
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [4]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]+
Blank [1]-
The Last Song [4]
Transformer [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [4]
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [4]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]
Blank [1]
The Last Song [5]+
Transformer [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

A Night Like This is gone. Great original but man, Iha cannot hit them lower register notes.

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [5]+
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [2]-
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [4]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]
Blank [1]
The Last Song [5]
Transformer [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

i'm still bummed about here's to the atom bomb losing judas 0

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [2]-
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [5]+
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [2]-
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [5]+
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]
Blank [1]
The Last Song [5]
Transformer [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [2]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [5]
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [2]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [5]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]
The Last Song [5]
Transformer [4]+
My Blue Heaven [3]

Blank is gone.

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [2]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [5]
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [2]
Pennies [2]-
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [5]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]
The Last Song [6]+
Transformer [4]
My Blue Heaven [3]

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [2]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [5]
The Boy [3]-
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [5]+
Tribute to Johnny [2]
Pennies [2]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [5]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]
The Last Song [6]
Transformer [4]
My Blue Heaven [3]

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [2]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [5]
The Boy [3]
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [5]
Tribute to Johnny [2]
Pennies [3]+
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [5]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]
The Last Song [5]-
Transformer [4]
My Blue Heaven [3]

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [2]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [5]
The Boy [3]
Cherry [3]
God [4]+
Mouths of Babes [5]
Tribute to Johnny [2]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [5]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]
The Last Song [4]-
Transformer [4]
My Blue Heaven [3]

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [2]
Destination Unknown [2]-
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [5]
The Boy [3]
Cherry [3]
God [4]
Mouths of Babes [5]
Tribute to Johnny [2]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [4]+
Rotten Apples [5]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]
The Last Song [4]
Transformer [4]
My Blue Heaven [3]


grrrrr Blanks gone before I even had chance to post
In my opinion this is probably the weakest survivor game with the best songs already used in previous games

Think Ill hit the cover songs with -ve first though seeing has they are not true pumpkin songs