ThePumpkins.net

not really. i think its the second low point of MI

everlasting gaze was left off because it's not that good. it's rehash and pretending. just because it's loud does not = good.

Here is a good playlist to try out:

Cash Car Star
Glass' Theme
With Every Light
The Imploding Voice
The Everlasting Gaze
If There Is a God
Stand Inside Your Love
Real Love
Home
Raindrops + Sunshowers
The Sacred and Profane
Wound
Glass and the Ghost Children
Heavy Metal Machine
I of the Mourning
Blue Skies Bring Tears
Speed Kills

doomsdayclock wrote:
yeah, you need TEG- i love that song

I wish there was a studio recording of "Pale Scales"...

We just don't have it yet

superchrist wrote:
That list seems very... stilted... O_O

Hmm, how so?

I took out "If There Is a God" and put in "The Crying Tree of Mercury instead...:

Cash Car Star
Glass' Theme
With Every Light
The Imploding Voice
The Everlasting Gaze
The Crying Tree of Mercury
Stand Inside Your Love
Real Love
Home
Raindrops + Sunshowers
The Sacred and Profane
Wound
Glass and the Ghost Children
Heavy Metal Machine
I of the Mourning
Blue Skies Bring Tears
Speed Kills

It's stilted because there's hardly a sense of flow of feel and mood, it's like you put Machina I and II on shuffle and picked the first few songs.

Actually it flows very nicely...

Cash Car Star and Glass' Theme --> With Every Light --> The Imploding Voice?

Home --> R+S??

Those songs could at least do with re-ordering. You gotta have songs that build up at the start, songs that keep it going in the middle, and songs that bring it all back down at the end.

I find that the first and second song are vital choices. I chose Lucky 13 and SIYL for 1st and 2nd. L13 is like a wake up call, it's a great first song and album starter reminiscent of I Am One. CCS was a good choice too, But I would suggest to put Glass before it, as it is perfect for an introductory track.

The second song I find has to be a good follow up, as if you listen to the album for the first time, get stunned by the first track, and then get that feeling confirmed with the second track.

Siva is great, Quiet is great, Frail is BRILLIANT (particularly because that album starts with a lull), Jellybelly is great, Bodies is great, Ava Adore is in the same boat as Frail, however in my opinion R+S is just a flop after The Everlasting Gaze.

SIYL is one of those tracks that is floaty from the start, but you can tell that there will definitely be a build up or a climax of some sort, so it's GREAT for a second track.

Well you know what: The beauty of this forum is that we are all allowed to have our own opinions. Unfortuneatly for you, my opinion doesn't match yours. So thanks but no thanks I guess, I like my tracklisting.

Aw man, all that writing for nothing.

I'm sorry.

PistolPete wrote:
i also agree we should have some of the demos and b-sides. they need some love. the original blue skies bring tears (arising!) is still one of my fav songs from the whole machina era. and is your "if there is a god (sad remix)" the track with the sound of rain in the background? if so that is one of my personal fav remixes.

i don't think you can include demos... i guess that's just my personal opinion.

Geek N.Z. wrote:

Well, here it is!

Autumn
Try Try Try (MII)
With Every Light
Here's to the Atom Bomb (Judas Ø)
Saturnine (MII)
Lucky 13
The Everlasting Gaze
Cash Car Star (LP)
The Imploding Voice
Heavy Metal Machine (M1)
Glass and the Ghost Children
Slow Dawn
Age of Innocence
Home

How's Autumn go again? It's been ages since I've heard that song.

I've never heard it.